Jason Kusner:the shrimp cocktail definitely lives up to the hype, it is a must get. Filet was good and the lamb is excellent.
Đang xem: Best shrimp cocktail restaurant
Leah Beyer:The shrimp cocktail is amazing and painful all at the same time. It is a must have if you go! Just be careful with the amount of cocktail sauce.
PureWow:St. Elmo is especially famous for its shrimp cocktail, which comes out with great to-do-four jumbo shrimp, on ice, with a generous dollop of cocktail sauce. And the steak’s pretty epic, too. Read more.
Chris Borland:The Filet was awesome. I liked the potato pancakes. The shrimp cocktail and seared tuna is incredible. Be careful the shrimp cocktail sauce will burn the hairs out of your nose. Read more.
Alison Cuomo:This is on my must do list in Indy. The shrimp cocktail is out of this world! Be prepared for sinus-gripping pain!
Daniel Yount:Shrimp cocktail was great! Do not make the mistake of putting too much sauce on!! However you have to order the Bread Pudding for dessert. To die for.
Christina Humphery:Great service. Great food. Great times. Get the shrimp cocktail and a pomegranate martini! Thank me later. ; )
Stu Coleman:Prime rib sandwich and calamari are a must! Shrimp cocktail is just as good as advertised. Prime rib pizza is also delicious.
Elena Barba:Shrimp cocktail..of course and the bar!
Amy Masterson:Obvious choice is the shrimp cocktail. Just as fabulous is the NY strip steak for 2
Joy Serbin:Tried the shrimp cocktail — the sauce was very string horseradish, cleaned my sinuses!!!
Brent Smith:Go to Eddie Merlot's and start a fantastic meal with the Smokin' Shrimp Cocktail. Not as hot as St. Elmo's but still yummy.
Paul V:Great food, great atmosphere, great service! Oysters and spicy shrimp cocktail are fantastic!
Ashish Kalgaonkar:It all amazing stuff. Just know that even for take out you can spend over 45 minutes to get your meal. Make sure you call ahead and order or plan to just sit down (if you can find the space).
Samantha Hurley:John is one of the best servers we've ever had anywhere! They are making the nuts for the salad request only so if you like them remember to ask and you'll get them. Not a bad thing on the menu.